Miami Dolphins Eye Bryce Young as Potential Backup for Tua Tagovailoa
With Tua Tagovailoa’s health concerns becoming a recurring issue, the Miami Dolphins are reportedly exploring options to bolster their quarterback depth. One intriguing proposal suggests a trade for Bryce Young, the No. 1 overall pick in the 2023 NFL Draft, currently benched by the Carolina Panthers.
The Dolphins have been performing well under head coach Mike McDaniel, but the uncertainty surrounding Tagovailoa’s future has raised questions about the team’s long-term strategy at quarterback. ESPN’s Bill Barnwell recently floated the idea of Miami offering a 2025 fourth-round draft pick to the Panthers in exchange for Young. The trade could address a critical need for the Dolphins while giving Young a fresh start in a system that plays to his strengths.
Tua’s Health and Miami’s Quarterback Situation
Tagovailoa’s concussion history has understandably cast a shadow over his career. Despite his talent and ability to lead Miami to victories, his health is a pressing concern. In recent seasons, the quarterback has suffered multiple concussions, leading to ongoing discussions about his long-term future in the NFL. Although Tagovailoa signed a long-term deal with the Dolphins, his health issues make it uncertain whether he will be able to play consistently or safely for years to come.
As a result, finding a reliable backup quarterback has become crucial for the Dolphins. Currently, Miami’s depth at the position is seen as a clear weakness, especially with Tagovailoa sidelined at times. The team needs an option that can step in and keep the offense running smoothly, and potentially someone who could take over if Tagovailoa’s health prevents him from continuing in the NFL.
Enter Bryce Young, a high-upside option who might be the solution to Miami’s quarterback dilemma.
Why Bryce Young?
Bryce Young, the top pick in the 2023 NFL Draft, was seen as a potential franchise quarterback when the Carolina Panthers selected him. However, his time in Carolina has not gone as planned. After struggling early in his rookie season, the Panthers decided to bench Young, sparking rumors that the team might be ready to move on from their initial investment.
Barnwell pointed out that while the Panthers have publicly stated they aren’t ready to part with Young, their decision to bench him tells a different story. The move signals that the team may be willing to entertain offers for the young quarterback, especially if they can recoup some value through a trade.
For Miami, Young represents a “high-upside” swing that could pay off in the long term. Although Young struggled early in his career, he has shown flashes of potential that made him the top prospect coming out of college. His ability to make plays with his arm and mobility fits well within McDaniel’s run-pass-option (RPO) offense, which could help him find success in Miami’s system.
Additionally, Young’s rookie contract is structured in a way that would make the trade financially feasible for the Dolphins. His four-year, $38 million deal included a $24.6 million signing bonus, most of which has already been paid by the Panthers. If Miami were to trade for Young, they would only be responsible for $10.7 million through the 2026 season, which is a reasonable price for a backup with the potential to develop into a long-term starter.
A Fresh Start for Young
A move to Miami could provide Young with the opportunity to reset his career in a new environment. The Dolphins’ offensive system, led by McDaniel, emphasizes quick decisions and creative play-calling, elements that could help Young thrive. Surrounded by weapons like Tyreek Hill and Jaylen Waddle, Young would have the support and talent around him that might allow him to reach his potential.
While the move wouldn’t be without risks, it could be a win-win for both teams. Carolina would get a valuable draft pick in return for a player they may no longer see as part of their future, while Miami would acquire a young quarterback with the potential to grow into a starting role if needed.
What This Means for Miami’s Future
If the Dolphins do decide to make this move, it could set them up for success both in the short term and the long term. In the short term, Young would provide valuable insurance in case Tagovailoa is unable to return to full health or sustain further injuries. He would also serve as a developmental player, allowing the Dolphins to groom him for the future.
Looking further ahead, if Tagovailoa’s health issues force him to step away from the game, Young could be the heir apparent. With his talent and potential, combined with a few years of experience in Miami’s system, he could become the Dolphins’ long-term starter.
In a league where finding a franchise quarterback is the key to sustained success, the Dolphins’ interest in Young could be a smart move to prepare for any scenario. The potential trade would not only address their immediate need for a reliable backup but also secure a high-upside player who could help shape the future of the franchise.